• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew

Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew is a true gem nestled in the heart of New York City, delivering an authentic taste of Philadelphia. Known for its legendary cheesesteaks crafted from thinly sliced ribeye or chicken and served on fresh Philly hoagie rolls, this sports bar captures the spirit of the City of Brotherly Love. Happy hour specials and a lively atmosphere, adorned with memorabilia from beloved Pennsylvania teams, make it an ideal spot for sports enthusiasts. Whether you choose their cheesesteak spring rolls or indulge in classic comfort like garlic battered cheddar bites, each dish promises generous flavors and exceptional quality.

Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew: Reviews & Ratings

Jim O.
Jim O.

As someone from Philadelphia, I can say that the cheesesteak with Whiz and fried onions is authentic. I now live in DC where I wish that there was a restaurant that served a cheesesteak this good. Thanks to Svetlana, who is an outstanding bartender.

Dani G.
Dani G.

I know I know I'm weird. I'm in New York and the first thing I crave at 11am is a cheesesteak. So I do a little searching and I come upon this place and I am so glad I did! The original cheesesteak with whiz was everything I was looking for and the regular French fries are the perfect ones we all love with that crunch on them. The bartender was very nice and Informed me that the bread is made in Philly and delivered to them in New York, I knew the bread tasted like "home". This is clearly a Pennsylvania bar with Eagles, Phillies, flyers, and Penn state stuff everywhere. The food was great, came out fast and hot and they had quite a few beers on draft. I'll def stop by again.

Alan L.
Alan L.

A comfortable neighborhood bar - especially if you're a Philadelphia Eagles fan. We stopped in on a NFL Sunday afternoon. The bar was full with Eagles fans, as were most of the tables. The cocktails were better than we expected them to be. The Cheesesteaks were similar to what you would find at a better restaurant in Philadelphia. The service was attentive.

Lawrence S.
Lawrence S.

I'm sorry this a review for the new upper east side location but I'm pretty sure I can blanket it. When I say these folks understand the art of cheesesteak. THEY DO! Service was phenomenal. Evan I believe the owner's name was very welcoming. I ordered the ghost cheese on my steak whew!!!!!!! It's hot for sure and worth the extra fun bucks. The fries were real great real American damn they make me not want fries from other places. One thing Philly natives know how to do is make great American cuisine. The decor is cool it's a real sports bar vibe. Make sure you pop out

Christina W.
Christina W.

Food and Service was amazing. They were patient and answered all of our questions. They have multiple cheese selections and fries

Lauren C.
Lauren C.

Discovered this place after seeing a show. I got the garlic aioli cheesesteak and Italian fries. The fries were $8 which I felt were pretty overpriced for the amount we received. I loved my cheesesteak - glad I didn't have to travel all the way to Philly for it! (I've driven to Philly just for cheesesteaks!) It was empty being that it was a Wednesday night but our food came out quickly. The decor was Philly themed highlighting their teams. They get their bread from Philly which makes the cheesesteak taste more authentic!

Courtney T.
Courtney T.

Had dinner in here the night of a Phillies baseball game and had no idea I was in NYC. This is definitely an all thing Philadelphia sports bar. The cheesesteak was delicious and perfectly cooked. I got ghost pepper cheese and it was serious! Fries Italian style, were ok. They had great flavor but were lukewarm and that's a no from me. Great service and atmosphere.

Nita W.
Nita W.

What a great find! My BFF and I were trying to find another place, but the directions on Google had us going everywhere but. So we decided after 20 mins of walking around 2-3 city blocks to have some beer and a philly cheesesteak after a long day of travelling. I am sure other reviews will be better at raving about this place, but here are my 2 cents. -beer-there's great happy hour offerings....we got a pitcher -the cheese steaks-made me happy and was tasty...enough said -service-friendly. she didn't hover and she didn't rush us out the place. We got to sit, chat, enjoy our meal and decompress. -If you like sports, there's tons of tv monitors for you to pick Definitely will come back here next time I am in the city. Unless Google maps messes with me again. Cheers!

Location

Welcome to Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew, a true gem nestled in the bustling heart of New York City! This spirited establishment, located at 576 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036, captures the essence of a classic Philadelphia sports bar while tantalizing your taste buds with genuine cheesesteaks and an impressive selection of brews.

At Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew, the philosophy is clear: serve food that brings comfort and nostalgia. The rich aroma of sizzling cheesesteaks fills the air, beckoning you to try their signature sandwiches, particularly the iconic cheesesteak with Whiz and fried onions—a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you're a Philadelphia native or a curious New Yorker, the reviews speak volumes. Jim O., a loyal fan, states, "the cheesesteak with Whiz and fried onions is authentic," underscoring the commitment to maintaining the true Philadelphia flavor.

  • Diverse Offerings: In addition to their legendary cheesesteaks, the menu features a delightful variety of appetizers like sauced tenders in flavors from classic Buffalo to Mango Habanero, and salads bursting with fresh ingredients.
  • Welcoming Atmosphere: The ambiance is welcoming for all, with a cozy sports-bar vibe adorned with memorabilia from Philadelphia sports teams, making it a favorite spot for fans on game day.
  • Exceptional Service: Customers frequently rave about the attentive service—an aspect that elevates the dining experience. From knowledgeable bartenders who recommend the perfect drink pairing to patient staff who answer every question, service is a priority.
  • Convenient Options: Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew provides ample convenience, offering delivery, takeout, and even catering. Want to enjoy your meal on the go? They even have a drive-thru option!
  • Happy Hour Specials: Make sure you take advantage of their happy hour specials, where you can enjoy quality food and drinks at attractive prices.

In a world bustling with endless dining options, Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew stands out. The mouth-watering cheesesteaks made with authentic bread from Philly, the satisfying crunch of their fries, and the lively atmosphere make it more than just a meal—it’s an experience that caters to your inner sports fan and foodie alike!

So what are you waiting for? Dive into the old-school charm of Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew, where every bite transports you to the streets of Philadelphia. Whether you're taking a break from the city life or actively cheering for your favorite team, this place promises a slice of culinary joy!

For more information or to place an order, give them a call at (917) 261-6869. Your cheesesteak adventure awaits!